| $ | CPTF | 11:52.94 | Crow, Cooley, Kuntz, Jennings | Furman |
| Lane | Team | Squad | Athlete 1 | Athlete 2 | Athlete 3 | Athlete 4 | Note |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | LYNC |
A | Burnett | Lagunas | Cholak | Ramsden | 2017 Colonial Relays |
| 2 | WC |
A | Schoen | Paraskeva | McKenzie | Steelman | VMI Winter Relays |
| 3 | W&M |
A | Jones | Cox-Philyaw | Lewin | Finikiotis | IC4A/ECAC Indoor Track & Field Championships |
| 4 | LOY |
A | Pugh | McHugh | Spinnler | O'Neill | |
| 5 | GMU |
A | Saine | Moore | Anderson | Freeland | Atlantic 10 Indoor Track & Field Championships |
| 6 | LOY |
B | Potticary | Kohaut | Malley | Ragone | |
| 7 | VMI |
A | Knoblett | Brooks | Luckett | Washington | |
| 8 | W&L |
A | Dieterle | Teagle | Gallagher | Harris | |
| 9 | C-N |
A | Naude | Nelms | Talbut-Smith | Strayer | South Atlantic Indoor T&F Championships |